“[Hiring] WordPress dev to fix a site a previous freelancer abandoned”
The tag tells you the poster came to hire, but do not read a stated budget into it — no rule on r/forhire requires one. What the rules guarantee is a floor: no spec work, no equity, no "pay what you want", and for hourly jobs nothing "under $15/hr". "Abandoned" is the operative word: there is a half-finished codebase, no documentation, and someone who has already been burned once. Quote the audit separately from the fix and say why. Then apply the way this sub requires — "Apply by PM or other private communication channels, not in comments" — because a reply in the thread is the one thing that gets removed here.
“Is it worth paying someone to build this or should I use a template?”
Not a price objection — a value question, asked before any budget has been set. The person is genuinely undecided, so the first useful answer usually frames the entire decision. Answer it honestly, including the cases where the template really is right, because the ones who should hire someone will identify themselves in the replies. Low urgency, complete decision authority, and a very long tail.
“How much should I expect to pay for a 5-page site in 2026?”
A budget is being formed in public, right now. Whoever answers with a defensible range becomes the reference point every later quote gets measured against, including yours. Give the band and the three things that move it — page count, custom design versus theme, and who writes the copy — and never give your own number. Urgency is low; influence over the eventual spend is enormous.
“Our Shopify theme broke after an app update - who fixes this?”
A live store is losing money, which makes this the most urgent phrasing here and the least price-sensitive. "Who fixes this" means they have already decided to pay someone and simply do not know the job title. Reply with the likely cause and how you would confirm it in ten minutes. Whoever diagnoses first usually gets the work, and the fix frequently becomes a retainer.
“Small business owner here, no idea where to start with a website”
No budget, no scope and no vocabulary yet — which is exactly why most designers scroll past it and exactly why it converts. Decision authority is total, because it is their own money. The winning reply is a short map of the decision they have to make before anyone can quote, not a pitch. Slow to close, and it usually arrives with no competing quotes attached.
“Need someone to migrate us off [platform] without losing SEO”
A stated constraint is a stated risk, and risk is what gets budget approved. This buyer has often already been quoted by someone who never mentioned redirects, and is now trying to work out who understands the danger. Name the specific failure modes — the 301 map, canonical drift, lost internal links — and the job is effectively decided. Mid urgency, high value, rarely a solo decision.